Your business is growing, and now the accounts are becoming too big to manage in your spare time. You start to think you need a CFO, a proper finance head for the money side. Then you find out what a good CFO is paid in a year, and you quietly drop the idea.
But let’s now find a different solution. The real question is not whether you need good financial help. You probably do by now. The question is how much of the services of an expert you need, and how often. Once you see it that way, the answer is usually clear, and usually much cheaper than that full salary.
The two choices, in plain words
A full-time CFO is a senior person you put on your salary roll. They come in every day, and running the money side is their only job.
A virtual CFO is also an experienced finance person, but they work with you only a few days a month, for a fixed fee. You get the same senior advice, without paying a full-time salary. In a separate post we have explained what a virtual CFO actually does day to day.
So the only thing to work out is which one your business needs right now.
When a full-time CFO is worth it
A full-time CFO is worth the money when there is enough finance work to keep a senior person busy all day, every day. That usually happens when a business is large or has many moving parts. Think high turnover, a few companies under one group, big loans to manage, or investors who want regular reports.
When a virtual CFO is the better choice
Many growing businesses have passed the point of managing with no senior help, but they don’t need someone every day. This is the spot a virtual CFO is made for, and for most small and mid-size businesses it is the smart pick.
It suits you when your accounts are being kept but nobody is really reading them. When you want clear monthly reports and a better grip on cash. When a bank or a buyer wants cleaner numbers. Or when you just want an experienced person to sit with you a few times a month and talk through the big money decisions. You get a senior head for a small part of the cost, and only for the days you actually need.
There is one more quiet gain. A good virtual CFO sets up the reports and systems that a full-time CFO would want anyway. So if you grow and do hire a full-timer later, everything is ready for them.
A simple way to decide
Forget the fancy titles. Just ask three plain questions.
- Is there enough finance work here to keep a senior person busy all week, or would they run out of work by Wednesday?
- Can the business pay a big monthly salary easily, in a slow month as well as a good one?
- Do you need someone sitting in the office every day, or do you mainly need good numbers and good advice at the right time?
If your honest answers are a full week, a salary you will not feel, and a need for someone there daily, then hire the full-time CFO. For most growing businesses, though, the answers point the other way, and a virtual CFO gives you what you really wanted without the weight of a full-time post.
Not sure which one fits you
This is an easy thing to decide with a chartered accountant, and a good one will not push you toward the costlier answer. A quick look at your turnover, your reporting needs and where you are heading usually settles it. If a virtual CFO is the right fit, a CA firm can take on that role for you. And if you genuinely need a full-time CFO, an honest advisor will tell you that too.
So if the CFO salary made you stop, you were not wrong to stop. You were just given two choices when there is really a third one in the middle. Pick the one that fits your business today. You can always move up to a full-time CFO later, when the business truly needs it.
Still not sure whether to bring in a CFO, and in what form? A short, no-pressure talk usually makes it clear. At Agarwal Ajay & Co we can help growing businesses make the correct call.